ccf-idea-reviewer

Assess research ideas for value, novelty, insight, and mechanism. Use for 思路审核, 靠谱吗, 值得做吗, 创新够不够, idea review, scoring, and ranking; no numeric-score request is needed. Default to concept-only review without experiment assessment, including ideas extracted from manuscripts. Developing an idea belongs to ccf-idea-optimizer; evaluating manuscript evidence or writing belongs to ccf-paper-reviewer.

Install

KitScout test notes

Not tested by KitScout yet. When our harness runs it, pros, cons and the tasks we tried appear here, with the date and evidence.

Similar tools

• wait-what
• karpathy-guidelines 232,934 ★
  Behavioral guidelines to reduce common LLM coding mistakes. Use when writing, reviewing, or refactoring code t
• discernment-nudge 194,218 ★
  After you give a substantive answer or draft that the user may act on — advice or recommendations, drafted art
• timeline-report
• weekly-digests